1 Following

A History Nut's Romantic State of Mind

"I never travel without my diary. One should always have something sensational to read in the train." - Oscar Wilde

Currently reading

Her Husband's Harlot
Grace Callaway
A Risk Worth Taking
Laura Landon
Texas Destiny
Lorraine Heath
Devil's Bride
Stephanie Laurens
Comanche Moon
Catherine Anderson
How the Marquess Was Won
Julie Anne Long
The Rake
Mary Jo Putney
The Other Guy's Bride
Connie Brockway
The Hawk and the Dove
Virginia Henley
A Dangerous Love
Sabrina Jeffries

The Hawk

The Hawk - Monica McCarty After having read [b: The Raider: Highland Guard #8|18007522|The Raider (Highland Guard, #8)|Monica McCarty|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1375757837s/18007522.jpg|25273782] and loved the story, I decided to go back to the beginning and pick up where I left off in the series, so to be speak. And that led me to this book, #2 in the series.

The hero, Erik MacSorley, is easy to imagine. I know quite a few Eriks myself and could just picture him. Oh he thinks everybody loves him and turns everything into a joke and thinks he is so smart. I guess it is pretty clear now how I feel about such characters?

Ellie was at the wrong place at the wrong time. She ended up being kept by Erik because nobody knew who to trust and in a time like Robert Bruce's Scotland, you most certainly do not trust anyone you just met.

I really have to say, I think Monica McCarty is a master of characterization. Her characters are vivid, to say the least, and are nothing if not authentic. Regardless how I feel about Erik or Ellie as characters, I cannot deny that they are eeriely real in the book. That much I can appreciate.

Now to the heart of the matter.

I liked Erik and Ellie well enough, though with wariness. A self-sacrifice, practical, responsible and plain heroine like Ellie is harder for me to like. But since she was away from her family most of the time, I was spared having to read her life as a mother hen, circling around her younger siblings. I mean, why does she have to be "responsible and plain"? Can't she be "irresponsible and plain" or "responsbile and beautiful"? I also admit openly that a pair of a handsome man and a plain woman just does not go down well for me. Erik being the well-loved cheerful handsome playboy that he is paired with Ellie, the plain but oh so responsible and practical 24-year-old maiden..........I do not love it.

But Erik and Ellie are good characters. Their relasionship developed on an island where Erik hid with his men and Ellie from the English. I enjoyed reading about them and how they came together. Erik is such a carefree character, the story took on a lighter feel which made it harder for me to take them seriously. I think it really depends on how one feels about the characterization. If this is your cup of tea, the story is well-developed and offers depth. If you have reservations, like me, you would love the story still, but from afar, if that makes sense at all.

I must compliment Monica McCarty on re-creating the Scotland of that turbulent time in her Highland Guard series. I have read quite a few different historical acounts of the real William Wallace and Robert the Bruce. To have characters from the losing side in history as leads is a daring attempt. Very cleverly done, I must say. The historical details are plenty but not over-powering the romance.